jump to navigation

Linspire 6.0: Two steps backwards? Or Hurt feelings? October 20, 2007

Posted by rjdohnert in 1.
trackback

Personally I disagree with the author of this piece.

I stick to my guns and will argue my point and the point here is the author is absolutely wrong. When I did my review of Freespire and I said I thought Freespire 2.0 was a better Ubuntu then Ubuntu, I meant it and I still agree with it.

What the authors leave out of that article is the fact that more hardware is supported then with the official Ubuntu release. Im not trying 7.10 because I keep getting frustrated with Ubuntu with every new release. 3D accelleration works with Linspire 6.0, all the common media files play out of box, and it doesnt unexplainably kernel panic and crash. The author brings up Linspire dropping things like LTorrent for KTorrent. What did LTorrent have over KTorrent? Not a thing, its a torrent application for Christs sake. NVU? NVU is dead and not being enhanced anymore, why litter the install CD with out of date code. I personally like that Linspire, Mandriva and PCLinuxOS dont enable 3D desktops by default, it should be users discretion whether to use that feature instead of hunting for an off switch. If you like the Ubuntu approach its not a bad system. Does it have its flaws? Sure but so does every OS on the market.

The main firing point here seems to be the patent deal and its wrong to hose a good piece of software just because of politics. The Microsoft deal could be good, could be bad, its still up in the air. The Microsoft deal with Novell has sprouted moonlight, an OpenXML translator for OpenOffice among many interoperability initiatives. While the patent deal seems to be a sore point I take the good with the bad and will wait to see how things turn out. That statement does not mean I think the patent deal is uneeded or a bad thing.

While I am not a poster boy for the Open Source movement, I dislike the GPLv3 and I disagree with Stallmans “Its GNU/Linux” philosophy. I even wish Theo Da Raadt would grow up. The last I heard was that the Open Source community was a community and that everyone can and should be involved and while Microsoft isnt jumping in head first, what they have contributed has been positive thus far. Should they calm down on the tongue service? Yeah they should, but that neighbor in the non virtual community who hates blacks, jews, puerto ricans, french and Starbucks should also quit blathering about. To the Linux and Open Source developers. If you dont like the idea that just anyone can take your code and profit from it, word of advice. Dont open source it.

In my personal and professional opinion if you want a better Ubuntu experience and still utilize the Ubuntu repositories and want a better Ubuntu then Ubuntu, give Linspire 6 a try. Do not jump on the bandwagon of an author who simply installed the system just to take a screenshot for an article. Give it a try and decide for yourself and dont let politics dictate your computing experience.

Advertisements

Comments»

1. My Ghillie » Linspire 6.0: Two steps backwards? Or Hurt feelings? - October 20, 2007

[…] Check it out! While looking through the blogosphere we stumbled on an interesting post today.Here’s a quick excerpt The Microsoft deal could be good, could be bad, its still up in the air…. The Microsoft deal with Novell has sprouted moonlight, an OpenXML translator for OpenOffice among many interoperability initiatives…. The last I heard was that the Open Source community was a community and that everyone can and should be involved and while Microsoft isnt jumping in head f… […]

2. Linspire 6.0: Two steps backwards? or just hurt feelings? - Noticias externas - October 20, 2007

[…] 6.0: Two steps backwards? or just hurt feelings? Read the rest here." Personally I disagree with the author of this […]

3. RS - October 20, 2007

I would disagree with that de Raadt thingy (well I’m bsd fan :P) – many people perceive him as little impulsive angry figure, well his posts sometimes look like this. I think he only stress things that really should be said.

In last incident, you probably know about it – linux devs relicensed BSD wireless code. De Raadt would get no attention without raising his voice, at first they did not listen to him and it took weeks for FSF figures to acknowledge their mistake.
Also I think it was right for him to stand up – BSD states that license should not be removed – this is vital – it’s harmless to people who create derivative work, while encouraging potential developers to submit their changes back in original license (even project). Without that in this case all new contribution would come back GPL-ed and useless to original developers.
They would effectively take over that piece of BSD code, while they so frantically threaten anybody that might break GPL license (Eben Moglen & family). Hypocrisy?

4. Ghillie Suits » Linspire 6.0: Two steps backwards? Or Hurt feelings? - October 20, 2007

[…] Check it out! While looking through the blogosphere we stumbled on an interesting post today.Here’s a quick excerpt of politics.  The Microsoft deal could be good, could be bad, its still up in the air.  The Microsoft… and that everyone can and should be involved and while Microsoft isnt jumping in head first, what they have […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: